The client is usually sure: a lawyer is a person who is one hundred percent on his side. Therefore, the phrase "I have a conflict of interest in this case" sounds strange and suspicious - it seems that the lawyer is simply looking for a reason to refuse. In fact, a conflict of interest is a situation when the lawyer physically cannot represent the client's interests impartially, because he is connected with the other side of the case. And recognizing this situation in time is the task not only of the lawyer, but also of the client himself.
A conflict of interest arises when the interests of a client conflict with those of another person with whom the lawyer is already professionally connected—a current or former client, a relative, or a business partner. In such a situation, the lawyer cannot act in the interests of both parties at the same time: by defending one, he inevitably harms the other. This is not a question of the integrity of a particular person—it is a structural problem that cannot be solved simply by “trying to be objective.”
The client rarely sees a conflict of interest directly, but there are indirect signals. The lawyer avoids a direct answer to the question of whether he has handled the opposing party's cases before. The defense strategy looks strangely cautious - as if the lawyer deliberately does not use strong arguments that could harm someone else. The lawyer knows the opposing party well personally - a former partner, a relative, a joint business. Or the client learns that the same lawyer advised the opponent before taking on his case. None of these signs alone proves a conflict, but their combination is a reason to ask a direct question.
A typical conflict of interest scenario depends on the category of the case — and it is easier for a client to recognize the problem when he understands how it manifests itself in his situation.
A conflict arises if the lawyer previously advised the Territorial Recruitment Centers or represented the opposing party in another case challenging the Military Medical Commission decision - then his knowledge of the "inner kitchen" may turn against you.
Directory of military lawyersA typical conflict is when a lawyer previously represented the interests of a bank or collection company in similar disputes and continues to cooperate with them, even if he formally undertook to defend the debtor.
Directory of credit lawyersA conflict is possible if the lawyer previously defended an accomplice in the same case or advised the victim - the interests of these individuals rarely completely coincide with the interests of a new client.
Criminal Lawyers DirectoryIf the lawyer has previously advised or represented the Pension Fund in similar disputes about recalculation or seniority, his assessment of the prospects of the case against the PFU may be unduly cautious.
Directory of pension lawyersThe most common case is that the lawyer has already represented the other spouse in another case or is in a family or friendly relationship with one of the parties to the conflict.
Directory of family lawyersIn most cases, a lawyer is required to disclose a conflict of interest and withdraw from the case on their own, even before signing the contract. But sometimes a conflict does not become apparent immediately — for example, when it turns out in the process that a former client of the lawyer is a witness or a third party. In such cases, a conscientious professional will report it as soon as they find out about it themselves. The problem arises when a lawyer either fails to notice the conflict due to inattention or deliberately silences it, hoping that the situation will "somehow be resolved."
The first is to ask a direct question: has the lawyer previously represented the other side of this case, does he have a personal or business relationship with the opponent? An honest answer, even an uncomfortable one, is better than silence. The second is to pay attention to whether the lawyer is avoiding certain arguments without explaining the reason. The third is to contact the Bar Qualification and Disciplinary Commission with a complaint if you have serious suspicions, and at the same time start looking for another specialist so as not to waste time on a case where the defense is already in question.
A conflict of interest is not an accusation of dishonesty, but a technical obstacle that exists regardless of the lawyer's intentions. It is important for the client not to be shy about asking direct questions on this topic: an honest answer at the beginning of the cooperation is much cheaper than a case spoiled due to hidden bias.
What is a conflict of interest for a lawyer, why does it arise, and how can a client recognize it in time to protect their rights?
A conflict of interest for an attorney is a situation where the attorney is connected to another party to a case: a current or former client, relative, or business partner. Because of this connection, the attorney cannot defend the interests of a new client completely impartially.
A conflict of interest for a lawyer arises when he has already consulted, represented, or has a personal relationship with the opposing party to the case - a bank, the Territorial Recruitment Centers, the Pension Fund, a relative of the opponent. By defending a new client, he risks harming the interests of the person with whom he is associated.
To recognize a conflict of interest, the client should pay attention to whether the lawyer avoids direct answers about connections with the opposing party, whether the defense strategy looks suspiciously cautious, and whether he has any personal or business relationships with the opponent.
In military cases, this is preliminary cooperation with the Territorial Recruitment Centers, in credit cases, representation of a bank or collector, in criminal cases, protection of an accomplice, in pension cases, consulting the Pension Fund, in family cases, communication with the other spouse. In each category, a lawyer's conflict of interest looks different.
Yes, a lawyer is obliged to report a conflict of interest and withdraw from the case as soon as he learns about it - often before signing the contract, and sometimes already during the conduct of the case.
First, it is worth asking the lawyer a direct question about his connections with the opposing party. If suspicions of a conflict of interest are confirmed or the answers are evasive, it makes sense to file a complaint with the Bar Qualification and Disciplinary Commission and start looking for another specialist to protect your rights.
Useful analysis, instructions and tips for customers
How to check a lawyer at Unified Register of Lawyers of Ukraine and avoid a scammer. Step-by-step instructions from a lawyer for a safe choice of a lawyer.
Read article →Why a popular lawyer often harms a case more than a narrow specialist. Risks of working with media lawyers.
Read article →Simple rules for preparing for a consultation with a lawyer. What information is important to provide to a lawyer in order to win the case.
Read article →How to choose a lawyer based on the profile of the case without relying on blind advertising and loud promises.
Read article →Should you trust a lawyer based on the advice of friends? What to really look for when choosing a defense attorney.
Read article →Why does a lawyer not guarantee the exact timing of the case and why are those who promise a quick result manipulating?
Read article →What does a lawyer do behind the scenes of the court besides writing a lawsuit? The full cycle of preparation for the court hearing.
Read article →What documents to prepare at home to speed up the lawyer's work and save your time and budget.
Read article →How many stages does a case go through before a lawyer files it in court? A step-by-step analysis of the procedural stages.
Read article →When a lawyer is required to refuse to handle a case in accordance with the rules of professional ethics and the law.
Read article →What is a conflict of interest for a lawyer, why does it arise, and how can a client notice it in time to protect their rights?
Read article →How does a lawyer assess the feasibility of a settlement for a client? When is it better to negotiate and when to go all the way?
Read article →How to file an official complaint against a lawyer with the QDCA. Procedure for filing and grounds for disciplinary action.
Read article →As an attorney, he uses the e-court system to quickly file documents and monitor cases.
Read article →Why the court address in the EUITS differs from the real data, and how does a lawyer check the court address and details before visiting the hearing.
Read article →How a lawyer explains the new and old names of Ukrainian courts to avoid confusion in procedural documents.
Read article →In which courts do the old names of districts still apply, according to a lawyer? A reference guide for the correct execution of papers.
Read article →An up-to-date list of changes in court jurisdiction for a lawyer in connection with current legislative changes.
Read article →How the cost of a lawyer's services is formed depending on the complexity of the case, the instance and the terms. Explanation without overstated promises.
Read article →What to look for in a contract with a lawyer before signing. Clauses that protect the client's interests.
Read article →Is it possible to agree on payment in installments with a lawyer and what installment options do lawyers offer in practice?
Read article →The hidden cost of a legal case — what costs the client does not immediately consider: court fees, expert opinions, translations. A complete list of costs that the client often does not consider.
Read article →The main myths about contracts from the practice of law. What the current legislation says about real obligations.
Read article →How a lawyer explains the real amount of payments under the law, dispelling myths about fixed interest rates.
Read article →Does the lawyer agree with the myth of automatic expungement of a criminal record after three years? Clarification of the rules from a lawyer.
Read article →When can a case be handled without a lawyer, according to lawyers, and when independent actions are guaranteed to lead to a loss.
Read article →Table of limitation periods by case category from a lawyer. A handy reference for plaintiffs and defendants.
Read article →Instructions for the first hours after detention while waiting for a lawyer. What to do according to the laws of Ukraine.
Read article →List of documents for court by case category from a lawyer. What you need to prepare for a military, family, credit and criminal case.
Read article → Shevchenko Andriy ViktorovychAsk a lawyer a question Duty lawyer online
